“I cannot make good choices unless I develop a mature and prudent conscience that gives me an accurate acount of my motives, my intentions, and my moral acts….The immature conscience is one that bases its judgements partly, or even entirely, on the way other people seem to be disposed toward its decisions. The Good is what is admired or accepted by the people it lives with. The evil is what irritates or upsets them. Even when the immature conscience is not entirely dominated by people outside itself, it nevertheless acts only as a representative of some other conscience. The immature conscience is not its own master. It is merely the delegate of the conscience of another person, or of a group…Therefore, it does not make real moral decisions of its own, it simply parrots the decisions of others. It does not make judgements of its own, it merely “conforms” to the part line. It does not really have motives or intentions of its own. Or if it does, it wrecks them by twisting and rationalizing them to fit the intentions of another. That is not moral freedom. It makes true love impossible. For If I am to love truly and freel, I must be able to give something that is truly my own to another. If my heart does not first belong to me, how can I give it to another? It is not mine to give!”
hard words, Merton, hard words… I read this passage, and was overwhelmed by the implications of these words. I have recently realized that I am a “pleaser.” I like to make people happy. And oftentimes, my words and actions are not a reflection of me, but rather of who I am directing them towards. This is not to say that I feel that I am being unfaithful to myself; if I feel strongly enough, I will stand up and risk making people unhappy. It is only since this realization have I been able to look at my thoughts, words, and actions, and see where it is I am basing my actions on the perceptions of others. Perhaps this is the first step?
Yet, perhaps what troubles me most about the implications of this passage stems not from my “pleaser” personality, but from the moral and spiritual development process itself. Having grown up in a conservative evangelical community, my morals have been basically handed to me: This is what a good Christian girl believes, does, and does not do. For the most part, I’ve accepted those morals. They’ve worked for me thus far.
But Merton implies that this simple acceptance of morality, of conscious (one’s definition of good and evil) hinders one’s ability to love… I’m not quite sure how he makes the connection, to be honest, but if he’s right…Can anyone love freely? Even with my years-long quest to understand what I believe, why, and to thoughtfully consider any challenges to those beliefs, I still recognize that at the root of my conscience are the moral foundations laid for me by my parents and conservative evangelical community… Over the years, I’ve tweaked them as I’ve been challenged to think. However, the fact remains that there is much I have not questioned, changed, or even challenged…
I don’t know…an interesting thought I should spend more time on, I think…